A
Catholic adoption society has won a High Court ruling that could lead to
it becoming exempt from having to consider gay couples as parents under
UK equality laws.
Catholic Care, based in the diocese of Leeds, West Yorkshire, says it
will have to give up its work finding homes for children if it has to
comply with the laws.
It came to court to challenge a Charity Commission refusal - backed
by the Charity Tribunal - to grant it an exemption from new equality
regulations which prohibit discrimination against same-sex couples
wanting to adopt.
Mr Justice Briggs, sitting in London, ruled the Commission had
misinterpreted Regulation 18 of the Equality Act (Sexual Orientation)
Regulations 2007, which allows for exemptions. The judge ruled the
purpose of 18 was to allow exceptions if they could be justified under
Article 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits
discrimination.
He said Catholic Care was in a very unusual predicament with
its status as an adoption agency of last resort for 'hard to place'
children. The arguably pre-eminent needs of those children who
will otherwise be left unadopted may constitute a very special and
unusual case for recognition under Article 14, quite unlike any other to
be found in the existing jurisprudence, but none the worse for that,
said the judge.
He ordered the Commission to reconsider the case and to analyse
whether an exemption was justified in the light of his judgment.
The judge's decision was warmly welcomed by Catholic organisations
but greeted with dismay by critics including the National Secular
Society, which described the ruling as the first major setback for
the protection of gay people from discrimination by religious groups.
Comment:
Adopting Hypocrisy
From JAK
After the Pope had to apologise for the Irish Catholic church
covering up child abuse by it's priesthood we get news that a Catholic
Adoption agency has won the right to exclude homosexuals from using
their services.
Perhaps the same service will protect children further by not letting
them near ANY Catholic priests... somehow I think not, it's fine to
cover up child abuse by your own people but not ok to be gay and give
kids a loving home.