A
TV ad, for Kronenbourg 1664 lager, began with a male voice-over that
said Lets open this new Kronenbourg 1664, with Dynamo Systeme.
The ad then showed a number of French professional chefs in a
kitchen. The chefs carried a very large bubble to a work surface, while
one chef said I want small bubbles, you know. The ad then showed
the chefs using culinary knives to rapidly slice the bubbles into
smaller bubbles. Other utensils were also used, including a grater, to
reduce the bubbles in size. One scene showed a chef looking into the
camera using a small knife to pop three bubbles. Another scene showed a
different chef moving quickly towards the camera holding a knife and
bursting a bubble in mid-air.
The ad ended with a close-up of the bubbles in a pint of the lager.
One of the chefs proclaimed lovely bubbles, while on-screen text
stated SMALLER BUBBLES. SMOOTHER TASTE.
Eight nutters challenged whether the ad:
- encouraged or condoned violence
- linked alcohol with aggressive or antisocial behaviour.
- One viewer challenged whether the ad linked drinking with an
activity which was potentially dangerous after consuming alcohol.
- The ASA challenged whether the ad was likely to appeal strongly to
under 18-year olds by reflecting youth culture.
Scottish & Newcastle UK Ltd (Scottish & Newcastle) said they took
their responsibilities as an advertiser very seriously. They said the
context of the ad was important and pointed out that knives were
legitimate tools for chefs practicing their trade. They felt that the
role of the knives in the ad was clearly defined and pointed out that
they were being used to chop and slice bubbles in a similar manner to
food being prepared in a professional kitchen and were not being used as
weapons in any way. They did not feel that the ad depicted or
condoned violence or antisocial behaviour.
Clearcast acknowledged that recent media reports had highlighted the
problems with knife crime. However, they endorsed Scottish & Newcastle's
response and added that they did not feel they could prevent ads from
showing knives being used in a legitimate manner. They pointed out that
the ad was somewhat surreal and, although the chefs were chopping
bubbles, the knives were used in a responsible manner.
ASA Assessment
1. & 2. Not Upheld
The ASA understood that there were serious concerns about knife crime,
particularly in light of a number of recent high-profile stabbings. We
did not dismiss those concerns lightly, however we considered that the
ad showed knives in an entirely different context. We considered that
the knives were not depicted as weaponry and the chefs did not engage in
threatening, violent or antisocial behaviour whilst using the knives.
Although the ad was shot in such a way as to give the impression of a
high-energy environment, we noted that the chefs did not appear
aggressive or antisocial at any stage. We concluded that the ad was
unlikely to encourage or condone violence, or link alcohol with
aggressive or antisocial behaviour.
3. Not Upheld
We acknowledged that the ad did not show alcohol being consumed in
the kitchen scenes. We noted that the scenes which showed the chefs
using their knives did not show any of the characters drinking alcohol
and we considered that it did not give the impression that they were
working under the influence of alcohol. We concluded that the ad was
unlikely to be seen as linking drinking with an activity which was
potentially dangerous after the consumption of alcohol.
4. Not Upheld
We considered that, because the dance track was over 10 years old,
and the song had not been made popular since, it was unlikely that it
would hold strong appeal for under 18-year olds.