The
BBC Trust, has approved the BBC set top box Project Canvas with certain
conditions.
UK broadcasters are collaborating on a common set top box, with IPTV
and web built-in.
The Canvas project copyrights vital parts of the technical
specification, which can't be seen except under NDA. Effectively this
hardwires the content into the silicon: like buying an FM radio in
Singapore and finding it only plays Singapore-approved content when you
get home.
The Trust makes four conditions for the BBC's continuing supports -
and demands that these be enshrined in the objects and shareholders'
agreement. The conditions are:
- The joint venture may develop ways in which to recover
operational costs but, for the avoidance of doubt, any such activity
will be charged to third parties on a cost recovery basis
only.
- Entry controls in terms of technical and content standards will
be minimal.
- Access will not be bundled with other products or services.
- Listing on the electronic programme guide and UI will be awarded
in a fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory manner.
OpenIPTV specs are by contrast, well, open and global. But basing a
Canvas box on truly open standards may have opened up the market much
wider. We can't be having that - UK viewers must be protected by having
a UK-only device serving up nice, UK-approved content in a UK-approved
manner. If it stays a UK-only platform and means fewer devices get made,
so there's less competition and higher prices, well, that's too bad.
|