A
Sunday Age investigation into Victoria's adult entertainment industry
has found storefront shelves heavy with tens of thousands of X-rated
films, which show real depictions of sex and are illegal to sell in
Australia outside the ACT and Northern Territory.
Victorian laws ban the sale of films that are X-rated, unclassified or
have been refused classification because they feature images showing
sexual violence, the offensive or demeaning treatment of women. What,
then, do the stocked shelves of our adult stores say about the state of
those laws?
As The Sunday Age discovered, adult stores openly flout prohibitions
against the sale of X-rated or unclassified films with seemingly no fear
of reproach. Rows of such DVDs are displayed brazenly on the shelves -
and for ease of reference are separated into categories such as "barely
legal", "golden showers" and "fetish".
At best, the law appears ineffectual - at worst, unworkable. Victoria
Police have the power to enter and search adult stores and to seize any
illegal material, but police sources complain such prosecutions are
typically time-consuming, protracted and ultimately unsuccessful.
On the record, Victoria Police will only say there is no evidence of an
increase in the illegal trade of X-rated or unclassified films, or films
that have been refused classification.
Our investigation suggests the contrary is true. Contradictions abound
not only between the law and its enforcement, but also in the
legislation as it is written. For example, while it is illegal to sell
X-rated material in Victoria, there is no law against buying it, owning
it or watching it here.
Tony Burke, president of the Law Institute of Victoria, says the state's
classification law is "anachronistic and ridiculous". However, he warns
that the failure of police to enforce the prohibition against the sale
of X-rated films could encourage wider illegality: There is a danger
that the law falls into disrepute. When the law is not enforced, it
throws into doubt the whole legal system of Australia.
Victoria's leading adult store owners say they already self-censor
"toxic product" such as sexually violent material. Angelo Abela, founder
of the Sexyland chain, says his stores refuse to carry films that
include bondage or abhorrent pornography.
Abela, a former muffler and spa salesman, says police are simply not
interested in enforcing the ban on the sale of X-rated films. No
one's come in to try to prosecute us. We have police come in and they
look at what we sell and they are fine with it, he says.
Club X boss Craig Hill boasts there has never been a successful
prosecution in Victoria for the sale of X-rated films.
In 2003-04, Victoria Police recorded 152 offences for breaches of the
classification law and arrested, charged or cautioned 64 people. Between
2006-07, those figures had plummeted to only 14 recorded offences and 12
people. Indeed, a Club X employee in Melbourne, who asked not to be
named, told The Sunday Age his store had not been raided by police since
1991.
Police, like the majority of our customers, are mature adults who
think that they should be able to watch what they want, when they want,
Hill says.
Professor Neil Rees, chairman of the Victorian Law Reform Commission
said: It is not unusual for there to be a gap between the law
as written on the books and what actually happens in practice, and that
may result from changing community attitudes and the government deciding
that the best approach is to sit quietly and do nothing until community
attitudes evolve to a point where there might be support for some
significant change in the law.
In this community 40 or 50 years ago, we had books like Lady
Chatterley's Lover banned. People would now look at this and think it
absurd. And my sense is that community attitudes towards the sort of
materials available now in the adult industry are evolving, so long as
possession is made by adults and not children.
The adult entertainment industry claims similarly to have the weight of
public opinion carrying it forward towards possible law reform. An
ACNielsen survey commissioned by Adultshop in September 2006 found only
30% of Australian adults said they were offended by explicit erotic
films. As many as three-quarters of those surveyed thought X-rated films
should be legally available to adults throughout Australia.
However, the national spokeswoman for the Australian Family Association,
Angela Conway, says there is still significant opposition within the
community to the sale of X-rated and unclassified films.
Meanwhile, the Victorian Government remains silent on the issue. When
asked about potential changes to the classification law, a spokeswoman
for Attorney-General Rob Hulls, who has previously admitted to watching
an X-rated film, simply says such issues are not "high on the agenda".
Michael Pearce, a vice-president of Liberty Victoria, says police have
rightly shifted their focus and limited resources away from the sale of
X-rated material to stopping the spread of child pornography. He argues
that beyond banning child pornography, adults should be allowed to buy
and sell whatever material they please: I can't see there would be
any demonstrated harm coming from this.