Gay Parades in Russia

The Moscow mayor's office has said it would not allow gay pride marches to take place on this year's May Day holiday.

The announcement came as a gay rights leader said he planned events throughout May to highlight the repression of sexual minorities in Russia.

The council will act decisively and uncompromisingly to prevent attempts to hold such events because society is overwhelmingly opposed to the gay lifestyle and philosophy, council spokesman Sergei Tsoi was quoted by Interfax.

It is a matter of surprise and indignation that gays plan to carry out unsanctioned gatherings in various parts of Moscow during the Festival of Peace and Work, Tsoi said, referring to May 1, one of the most important Soviet-era holidays.

He said the council was taking into account threats of violence made by radical Orthodox and other anti-gay groups: There could be bloodshed and no one wants that.

Moscow Mayor Yury Luzhkov has been an outspoken opponent of gay pride marches, referring to them once as "Satan's work."

The leader of the pressure group Gay Russia, Nikolai Alexeyev, said the group planned to apply for permission to hold five events a day throughout May in various parts of Moscow. He added that the events would not resemble the flamboyant carnival atmosphere synonymous with such marches in Western cities: If everyone sees that these people are not nude or wearing make-up... there will be many questions about why this event was banned.

Gay rights activists protested in defiance of a City Hall ban on Sunday, marching in front of the Moscow State Conservatory and unfurling a banner demanding greater rights for gays and lesbians from the window of an apartment on Tverskaya Ulitsa, just blocks from the Kremlin.

Dozens of activists from Gay Russia, led by organization head Nikolai Alexeyev, held a series of separate protests throughout the city to try to avoid exposing protesters to some of the violence that accompanied the larger gay pride parades in 2006 and 2007.

We wanted to make this pride [day] different from the last two years, Alexeyev said in English. We didn't want to have any more beatings in the street. We just want to show everyone that we are normal people.

City Hall rejected more than 100 requests by the group to hold their annual gay pride parade in May, citing security concerns. Mayor Yury Luzhkov is a fierce opponent of the parade and his office has denied every parade request since 2005, a move upheld as constitutional by the Moscow City Court in April 2007.

The protests were much more peaceful than in recent years. Despite the lack of violence, the mood on Sunday was hardly festive.

Screaming anti-gay protesters threw garbage and rotten eggs at the apartment on Tverskaya. One woman was detained after lifting a banner that said, Mr. President, stop these sodomites from leading us down to the path to death!

A massive security presence was visible early in the afternoon, as hundreds of regular officers and OMON riot police lined Moscow's main thoroughfare, blocking access to Tverskaya Ploshchad.

We're protecting the children, said a police officer, who refused to give his name. Do you think it's proper for [gays] to come out into the streets like this? Well, I don't.

Moscow's mayor, who has banned gay rights parades in the past, vowed Thursday to continue his ban on what he called sexual minority propaganda, according to Russian news agencies.

Mayor Yuri Luzhkov, who has called homosexuality satanic, said City Hall has banned, and will continue to ban, the propaganda of the views of sexual minorities. Those views, he is quoted as saying, could become one of the factors for the spread of HIV.

City Hall has rejected repeated requests by public organizations to draw attention to gay rights with parades. Attempts by activists to defy the ban have ended violently in some cases and petered out in others.

A gay parade planned to coincide with the Eurovision Song Contest, hosted by the Russian capital, has been banned by Moscow because it will destroy morals, a spokesman for the city's Mayor said.

The Moscow government is saying: Moscow has never had gay parades and it never will, said Mayor Yuri Luzhkov's spokesman, Sergei Tsoi. Not only do they destroy morals within our society, but they consciously provoke disorder.

Parade organiser Nikolai Alekseyev said the event would take place: This is our right and it is guaranteed by the constitution. No official, including the Moscow Mayor, has the right to violate it.

But Mr Luzhkov's spokesman said any attempts to hold an unsanctioned gay parade would be toughly stopped by law enforcement agencies in accordance with the law.

Update: Tatchell Arrested

17th May 2009. See article from independent.co.uk

Riot police in Moscow ruthlessly broke up a peaceful gay rights protest, at times using violence to detain the participants. The city authorities had banned the march, timed to coincide with the supposedly gay-friendly Eurovision Song Contest, but around 30 activists decided to protest anyway, changing the venue at the last minute.

They gathered near Moscow's main university, chanting slogans and unveiling banners protesting against homophobia in Russian society. Most of the demonstrators, including the organiser, Nikolai Alexeev, and British gay rights campaigner Peter Tatchell, were bundled into police vans and driven away. The city's mayor has previously referred to gays as Satanists and the authorities claimed the march had been banned to prevent moral degradation.

Tatchell was released without charge in the afternoon after the British Embassy requested consular access to him, but most of the other participants in the gay demonstration were still being held by police.

A planned gay rights parade will not be able to take place in Moscow after the usual ruling by its mayor, Yuri Lushkov, the Itar Tass news agency reported .

Lushkov, who has taken anti-gay stances in the past, called the Gay Parade a blasphemy as he announced that he would not let it go forward as planned in Europe's biggest city.

We have never approved this kind of parade before and we are not going to do it in the future, said Lushkov, who said he was exercising the will of Muscovites. He also pronounced rallies and demonstrations by gay and lesbian groups as Satanic dealings.

Organisers of last year's first-ever Moscow Gay Pride have today formally taken their case of the ban by the authorities in the Russian capital of both a parade and a picket to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France.

This follows the unsuccessful appeals against the bans through the Russian court system, which are now exhausted, as far as requirements of European Court's jurisprudence are concerned.

The organizers are considering appealing pride bans to the Russian Supreme Court parallel to their European Court application though it will not effect the consideration of the case in Strasbourg.

At the same time, Moscow Pride organisers announced that this year's Moscow Pride will definitely be going ahead, and that an application for a parade will be made in accordance with Russian law, two weeks before the event, scheduled for Sunday May 27, the day in 1993 when homosexuality was decriminalised in Russia.

The application to the European Court of Human Rights combines two cases: one concerning the ban by Moscow authorities of the gay pride march and the second concerning the banning of the alternative pride picket, both scheduled for May 27, 2006.

In the application, the litigants claim that in denying permission to stage both the march and the picket the Russian Federation breached Article 11 (right to freedom of peaceful assembly), Article 13 (right to effective court protection) and Article 14 (discrimination ban) in conjunction with Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights, to which Russia is a signatory.

Moscow police have detained several gay rights opponents at the first sanctioned gay rights protest in years, marking a sharp reversal of policy after last week's dismissal of the city's notoriously intolerant mayor.

Moscow Mayor Yuri Luzhkov had compared gay people to the devil, and gay rights rallies in Moscow were forbidden. Many went ahead regardless and were violently dispersed under his leadership. He was fired this week after President Dmitry Medvedev said he had lost faith in him.

Two dozen activists protested Friday outside Swiss International Air Line's Moscow office against the carrier's alleged role in the kidnapping of the leader of Russia's gay rights movement, which sparked concern in Western Europe.

Nikolai Alexeyev is widely known in the international gay rights movement for his repeated efforts to organize parades in Moscow. Alexeyev alleges the airline removed him from a boarding gate at Domodedovo Airport at the behest of four unidentified men, not in uniform, who took him to a police station.

Alexeyev was to board a flight to Geneva but instead was taken to the nearby town of Kashira and, he told The Associated Press, insulted with all the slang words for homosexuals in the dictionary and commanded to withdraw complaints filed against Russia at the European Court of Human Rights

On Friday, Alexeyev and the other activists held aloft posters accusing the Swiss airline of complicity in kidnapping, while police arrested at least four protesters trying to sabotage their rally.

The police worked professionally, and we are thankful to them, said Alexeyev, who has been roughed up and detained several times by police in the past. They protected us.

The European Court of Human Rights has fined Russia for banning gay parades in Moscow, in an important victory for the country's gay community.

A leading activist, Nikolai Alexeyev, brought the case after the city authorities repeatedly rejected his requests to organise marches.

The Moscow authorities had argued the parades would cause a violent reaction.

But the court in Strasbourg said Russia had discriminated against Alexeyev on grounds of sexual orientation. It said that by refusing to allow the parades, the authorities had effectively approved of and supported groups who had called for (their) disruption.

The mere risk of a demonstration creating a disturbance was not sufficient to justify its ban, the court said. It ordered Russia to pay Alexeyev 29,510 euros ($41,090) in damages and for legal fees.

This is a crippling blow to Russian homophobia on all accounts, Alexeyev said after the verdict was announced: The authorities now have to ensure the security of peaceful gay activists, and must allow our protests to take place in Moscow or any other city in Russia. We will be applying to hold a sixth gay pride event in Moscow in May 2011. We'll be taking the former Moscow mayor Yuri Luzhkov to court: he broke the law by blocking our protests.

Yuri Luzhkov, who was mayor of Moscow for 18 years before he was sacked last month by President Dmitry Medvedev, described homosexuals as satanic.

A rally against gay parades, legalization of same-sex marriages and immorality propaganda gathered some 1,000 protesters on Bolotnaya Square in central Moscow.

The rally was organized by a number of Orthodox organizations and began with a prayer. Many people carried icons and signs reading We do not need gay parades!, A gay parade will never be held in Moscow, and others.

The rally followed the recent ruling of the European Court of Human Rights that Moscow's ban on gay pride marches is illegal.

Vladimir Khomyakov, a co-chairman of the Narodny Sobor (People's Gathering) Orthodox organization, said, Despite the stories about our belligerent homophobia, we have never urged and are not urging to destroy gay clubs and attack gays. We have come to claim that the ECHR ruling is a gross interference in Russia's domestic affairs and a violation of the Russian constitution and international law.

 Moscow Mayor Sergei Sobyanin has said that gay parades in Moscow are still inadmissible, ruining hopes of the Russian gay community for holding sanctioned sexual minority events.

Sobyanin told the Ekho Moskvy radio station that he doubts any gay parades will be held in the Russian capital: Moscow does not need this at all and I am not a supporter [of gay parades].

Requests to hold gay pride marches, described by ex-mayor Yury Luzhkov as satanic, have been rejected by the Moscow authorities for years.

Moscow city officials have rejected an application for a gay pride parade to be held in the city center later this month, claiming a risk of public disorder, organizers said.

Gay rights activists had applied to hold a parade called Moscow Gay Parade: Homosexuality in the History of World Culture and Civilization, which they expected would draw more than 5,000 people to a city park near the Kremlin on May 28. Previous attempts to hold a sanctioned parade have been banned and violently broken up.

Former Moscow mayor Yury Luzhkov, who was fired in September, called gay pride events satanic. His successor Sergei Sobyanin has allowed opposition activists to hold authorized demonstrations, and there were hopes that he would sanction the parade.

But on Tuesday, the group led by prominent gay rights activist Nikolai Alexeyev received a letter from city council saying that Moscow city government considers it is justified in not permitting the announced event to go ahead, organizers said in a statement, AFP reports.

The letter reportedly said that public gatherings could be banned to keep order, preserve morality or protect the rights and freedoms of others. Moscow authorities said they had received letters from religious and traditional groups threatening protests if the event was not banned.

Alexeyev told the Associated Press that this was the sixth time authorities had refused the request for a rally, and that activists would go ahead with a peaceful demonstration despite the ban.

Moscow police have detained three prominent foreign gay rights leaders and a number of local activists after religious extremists attacked them.

The gay group had planned to lay a wreath at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier near the Kremlin wall.

A group of ultra-Orthodox Christians attacked the protesters, who were waving rainbow flags and some carrying signs reading Russia is not Iran, and preparing to stage the unauthourised demonstration.

Police moved in and wrestled both activists and members of the religious group to the ground before leading them off in handcuffs to waiting security vans.

Those detained included French gay rights activist Louis-Georges Tin and the US's Dan Choi and Andy Thayer. British gay rights campaigner Peter Tatchell said that the police tried to lead him away as well but that he had managed to break free.

A Moscow police representative told Moscow Echo radio that 34 activists had been detained within the first minutes of the rally.

Tatchell claimed to have seen three police buses packed with people who looked like skinheads and neo-Nazis parked outside the Moscow mayor's office: Our suspicion is that they were police officers in civilian clothes. We suspect that a sizeable portion of the neo-Nazis were actually undercover police officers.

Update: Church thanks Russian state for beating up gay pride participants

Thanks to National Secular Society
25th May 2011. Based on article from minivannews.com

The Russian Orthodox Church is grateful to the Moscow city authorities and law enforcers for preventing a gay parade attempted in the city last Saturday.

Responding to questions from Interfax-Religion on Monday, head of the Synodal Department for Church and Society Relations Archpriest Vsevolod Chaplin said the authorities quite politely prevented an instance of propaganda of homosexuality which could have been witnessed by children and teenagers who crowded the two venues of the action.

He expressed hope that in the future the authorities of Russia and Moscow in similar cases will listen to the voice of their own people, the majority of whom do not accept the propaganda of homosexuality, instead of foreign pressure that was exerted before the action and continues now.

The clergyman said that on the basis of an absolutely clear moral choice of the people Russia can restrict any propaganda actions. I am deeply convinced of that. International organizations and especially the governments of countries with whom we have different histories and different social systems should realize that, Father Vsevolod said.

He added that he found the beatings on Saturday 'regrettable'.

Moreover, he admitted that he had never heard of the Orthodox Brotherhood blamed for the beatings. It is the first time that I have heard about such an organization. I wonder whether it was set up for provocative purposes, Father Vsevolod assumed.